Uncomfortable Truths About Reincarnation
that Challenge the Ego
The mere mention of reincarnation usually awakens a mixture of fascination and fantasy. Almost everyone who explores their past lives seems to have been great kings, Egyptian priestesses, or legendary warriors. However, an inevitable statistical question arises: where are the millions of peasants, swineherds, and serfs who made up the bulk of history? The idea of reincarnation, often manipulated by personal vanity, has become a "narcosis"—as Hermann Hesse would say—a sedative to evade the mediocrity of the present instead of being a path of profound understanding. For the seeker of the Philosophia Perennis, reincarnation is not a consolation for the ego, but a metaphysical enigma that demands we question who we truly are. What we call "I" is, frequently, a projected shadow, a ray of sunlight reflected in a mirror that we mistake for the source of light.
The Trap of Vanity: The Spiritual "Like"
The concept of reincarnation is used today to feed the ego and justify the dissatisfactions of the present. We search the past for an importance that we feel we lack today, projecting ourselves as resplendent figures to compensate for our current smallness. This "infinite vanity" clashes with historical reality: there simply were not enough Cleopatras or Napoleons to satisfy the demand of the millions of people who today claim their thrones. Even the question "do you believe in reincarnation?" has become a marker of social identity, a simple "like" or "dislike" to classify ourselves into acceptable groups. But the truth is harsher: identifying with illustrious characters is a distraction from genuine spiritual work. As critical reflection rightly points out: "No one remembers being the incarnation of a poor beggar; almost everyone remembers having been great kings, princesses, or wise priests, which is usually rather a sign of infinite vanity."
The "I" is a Square Without a Real Center (The Illusion of the Quaternary)
For the Immemorial Wisdom, the human personality is not a fixed entity, but a "quaternary" composed of four interdependent and transitory elements:
The Physical: The dense body and its organs.
The Energetic: The subtle systems that distribute vitality (Prana).
The Emotional: The movements of attraction and repulsion (Kama).
The Mental: The framework of ideas and thoughts. This "I" is dependent: if you suffer an accident or an illness, your center of gravity shifts, your emotions change, and your mind adapts. You are "another person." This personality is a puppet theater full of opinions. However, this square only acquires stability if it becomes the base of a pyramid anchored to something superior: the Spirit. Without that anchorage to what belongs to a higher plane, the personal "I" is merely a shadow that dissolves upon the death of the body. Projecting this conditioned "I" into the future is a falsehood, for the being we will be shall be configured by forces that today we do not even suspect.
The Six Realms: Reincarnation as a Psychological State
We often imagine the Buddhist "realms of rebirth" as physical places, but their esoteric interpretation is much more unsettling: they are also the psychological states in which we reincarnate according to our acts. Thus, we can be born in the realm of:
The Animal World: When we live guided exclusively by instinct and the search for sensual pleasure.
The World of Hellish Beings: When we are trapped in the suffering of fixed ideas and memories that torture us.
The World of Hungry Ghosts: The state of insatiable desire, lack, and perpetual frustration.
The World of Demigods: The powerful slaves of their own ambition and ego.
The World of Gods: Those who live in the "narcosis" of rest and glory, forgetting the urgency of liberation.
The Human World: The only state of equilibrium between tears and laughter where it is possible to achieve true freedom.
And also, similarly, we are reborn every day in each of these worlds when we allow an emotion or a desire to dominate us, or on the contrary, we come more close to the liberation when we become aware of our human reality and decide to change for the better.
Technical Distinction: Incarnation, Reincarnation, and Rebirth
To avoid credulity, we must be precise with terms. Not everything that returns is the same:
Incarnation: The manifestation of "something" (conscious or not) in a human body.
Reincarnation: When that "something" that enters proceeds specifically from a previous life.
Rebirth: The mutation of a being into something different, but maintaining a continuity of consciousness, though not necessarily with the same structure of identity. For Buddhism (the formal religion), these reincarnations correspond to what is called Samsara or the "perpetual wandering," a cycle of old age and death that must be extinguished. But for Budhism (with a single 'd', the Immemorial Doctrine of Wisdom or Bodhi), this pilgrimage is the method by which the One Life distills experience through its infinite manifestations.
The Secret of Tibet: Rangtong versus Shentong
There exists a philosophical conflict that was silenced for centuries for political reasons. The predominant Buddhism today (Gelugpa school) teaches Rangtong, that is, the “Emptiness of Self”. This doctrine affirms that behind phenomena there is nothing; it is, in essence, a scientific materialism in monk’s robes, viewing Nirvana as total annihilation. Most people ignore this.
Opposed to this arised the Shentong (Other-Emptiness) view, preserved by the Jonang school, which almost disappeared. This vision maintains that, while the world of appearances is empty, there nonetheless exists an Absolute Reality and immutable: the so called Buddha-Nature. This essence is present in all human beings; it is a seed of the Buddha, in other words: our eternal nature. And this is the "escape" from the world of the created. As the ancient sutra say:
"There is an Unborn, Unoriginated, Uncreated, and Unformed. If there were not this Unborn... escape from the world of the born, the originated, the created, the formed, would have been impossible."
This is the "Jewel in the Lotus" (Om Mani Padme Hum): the seed of immortality that survives the shipwreck of the personality.
The Internal Engine: About Masters and Mirages
One of the great traps is blind submission to "gurus" who promise Nirvana in quick courses, like someone selling a book on "Chinese language in seven days". This subservience halts evolution. The human beings must find their own Internal Engine, the capacity to rise after every fall through their own effort. True progress is not achieved by "looking upward" to gain merit before an “illuminated” hierarchy, but by looking "downward and to the sides," serving the most disadvantaged brothers. That which is above opens only when we take care of that which is below. What survives is not the name nor the diplomas, but the pure distilled experience, an indefinable aroma that remains when the material dissolution takes everything else away.
Conclusion: From "I" to "We"
Our current personality is simply a role in the theater of life destined to perish. I, who have a name and titles, will cease to exist. But the mystery that drives me, that which lifts me after every failure and leads me to serve others, is eternal. At the end of the act, the question is not whether you were Cleopatra, but whether you have managed to awaken to what Hermann Hesse called "the great secret." Liberation is not a conquest for the "I" or the personal ego (which is illusory), but the recognition of a superior reality. At the summit of the spiritual mountain, we discover the final truth that dissolves all vanity: There is no "I"... there is "We." Only what you build today to enlighten another human being will be truly worth giving back in the next act of life.







